How to tell if you have a bad neutral safety switch




Back in the day, when you’d go to start a car it would be entirely possible for you to bump the starter and have the vehicle just take off.  This would cause damage to property, other vehicles, and even human life.  The Neutral Safety Switch was invented to curtail this issue.  The neutral safety switch is a switch that can be mounted anywhere that keeps the vehicle from starting in gear.  It is one of many safety features that modern cars have, and it is one that rarely ever has a problem.  A bad neutral safety switch can really be difficult to pinpoint.  This should never be your first conclusion if you are troubleshooting why your car won’t start

There are two different ways that a neutral safety switch can go bad.   The first way is that the switch remains on at all times.  That will cause nothing to happen when you turn the key.  The other is that the car will start in gear.

The Car Starts in any Gear

Well, the good news about this one is that at least you won’t be stranded anywhere.  In fact, you may only be aware of it because the service engine soon light came on.  It is still a good move to go ahead and get the Neutral Safety Switch removed.  It only takes one mistake to damage something.

 

The Car Won’t Start at All





If you turn the key and it doesn’t feel like the starter is engaging, then you probably have a bad neutral safety switch, but not necessarily.  Let’s go over some practical troubleshooting to help verify this.

  • You turn the key and the engine doesn’t start, but you here one click coming from the engine when you turn the key. That clicking sound is more than likely the starter solenoid.  You probably have a bad starter motor.  It is a much more common issue than a bad neutral safety switch.
  • Turn your headlights on. Get a friend to stand in front of the vehicle or find something reflective to let you see your lights (or turn of the light and close the garage door if you are lucky enough to be in a garage with this problem).  Now turn the key.  If the lights stay on and bright than it could be the neutral safety switch.  You were checking to make sure that you didn’t have a bad battery or battery connection.  If your lights did dim really bad you may wish to check and see if the battery is corroded.  Follow this YouTube tutorial to fix a corroded battery issue.

 

 

  • Security system. Many vehicles have a security system that will activate the neutral safety switch in order to keep the vehicle from starting.  The security light will usually go out with all of the other lights on the dash.  If it stays on, than that may be the issue that is keeping the vehicle from starting
  • Many vehicles also have a switch that only lets you start the vehicle with the brake pedal pushed in. This is not as common as a neutral safety switch, but worth looking into.
  • It could be a locked engine. That will keep it from turning over.  Unless you have some reason to believe that you’ve run the motor out of oil, this is way less likely than the neutral safety switch going bad.

 

How the Neutral safety switch works in a manual transmission

The neutral safety switch in a vehicle with a manual transmission is going to look a heck of a lot like a brake light switch.  It works in the same fashion as the brake light switch.  It will allow the vehicle to start in any gear, but it’ll only fire if the clutch is pressed in all of the way (even in neutral).

 

How the Neutral safety switch works in an automatic transmission

On more modern vehicles, it is often located where the shift linkage attaches to the transmission on modern vehicles.  It could also be somewhere on the column.  You’ll need to consult your repair guide or the internet (you’re already there anyway!) to find the exact location of your neutral safety switch.  The neutral safety switch allows the car or truck to start in both park and neutral.  Both of these “gears” are not really gears.  They provide neither forward or rearward momentum.

 

I’m Stuck NOW!

Are you stuck somewhere and your pretty sure that you have a bad neutral safety switch?   Try this to get you out of jam so you can get home or somewhere safe to make the repair.

 

  • Older Fords are notorious for needing a little help to engage the safety switch. Try lifting the column shifter higher like there is a gear above park.  At the same time you do this keep the key turned in the forward position to engage the starter if it works.  This works on a lot of vehicles.  Try this on any make of vehicle
  • Keep the key toward start and rock the steering wheel back and forth. Sometimes the mechanism that keeps the vehicle in park won’t engage all the way.  This is why you should ALWAYS use your parking brake.  When you rock the wheel you’ll be settling the transmission and it may start
  • Put the vehicle in Neutral. It may not work in Park, but it may work in Neutral!  Simple right?  This works a surprisingly high amount of time.
  • Keep your foot firmly on the brake. Turn the key to engage the starter and shift through all of the gears.  You may very well end up engaging the Neutral Safety Switch in a gear it’s not supposed to work in.  If this works you’ll be starting the car in gear so don’t just take the foot off of the brake until you are in the gear that you need to put the transmission in.
  • If you have a manual transmission keep the key turned, your foot on the brake, and the key turned forward.  You’ll want to keep pushing the clutch pushed down.  It may engage the neutral safety switch.

 

It’s not very likely that you’ll have any sort of issue with a neutral safety switch over the life of a modern car, but if you do I hope this helps.  Thanks for reading!

Posted in tech

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*